Time to revolt
A rethinking seems to be necessary. As several committed personalities have pointed out, does high-level sport, as it is defined and built, still have a place in a world of energy contraction?
How long will it be possible to consider, for example, that European soccer clubs can go to Asia one week, the United States the next, and Qatar the week after? How is it that these clubs can still spend hundreds of millions of euros on salaries and transfers when they can't seem to "invest" a few tens of thousands in a social or environmental impact strategy?
How is it that some major international federations are still sponsored by polluting or health-destroying industries?
I wonder about the strategic priorities of these organizations. What are their objectives? Always more growth? Always more entertainment? Always more financial speculation? Always more geopolitical interference? What are the societal missions have they clearly identified? What are their reasons for being?
Does the governance of these organizations include in their strategic roadmap, the regeneration of natural ecosystems, the preservation of life, and the contribution to the common good as a primary principle? How do they organize themselves and work to solve societal problems in a sustainable manner?
Is there really a defined CSR strategy in place or is it just a matter of opportunity, a bit of "green paint", opportunistic statements, calls for tenders without any real structure? Why do these social and environmental impact issues seem to be driven solely by communication or purchasing departments with a view to "doing well", in a tactical manner, and not embodied by management?
Why carry out short-term actions or projects that are completely disconnected from the realities and limits of the planet's ecosystems? Why carry out actions only by mating, only under the fruit of a growing societal pressure?
I wonder about the respect of scientific standards and alerts (Science Based Target, etc.) and the consideration of social-climatic issues. In a world where we (normally) respect the Paris Agreement and where everyone should have a maximum carbon footprint of 2t of CO2/eq, we have to ask ourselves if the economic models of these organizations are still viable.
In any case, it seems more necessary than ever that sports organizations integrate a real strategy of eco-responsibility, supported by sincere, enlightened and educated governance, federating all stakeholders in a common approach, in a common, positive impact project. This will not only create economic and societal value but will also ensure the long-term development of these organizations.
Clubs, federations and ministries have the opportunity to position their environmental approach as a strategic pillar and a lever of innovation within all their departments or sectors of activity (management, finance, communication, accounting, etc.), jointly with all their stakeholders (private partners, institutions and public authorities, athletes, supporters, staff/collaborators).
The vision and proposed actions will therefore be anchored in a development logic allowing them to: reduce their physical and transitional risks related to global warming and biodiversity erosion; generate revenues, retain and acquire new partners; optimize and retain current partnerships by allowing brands/institutions to activate their commitments with the new CSR approach; open up new categories and increase its attractiveness to new partners looking for assets that allow them to express their raison d'être; increase fan engagement and conquer a new audience.
Fans and the general public want to get involved in solving major societal challenges, especially the environment; to increase the attractiveness of the club and boost the recruitment of committed sportsmen and women (and therefore more successful on the field); to engage the club's stakeholders beyond the club's performance and prestige; to retain employees within the organizations and attract new talent.
Finally, I wonder about the consistency and balance of the value scales. I am still very surprised by the budgets allocated to certain salaries, transfers, and media activations when only 0.01 per cent of some of these amounts would be more than enough to initiate the integration of a structural and differentiating CSR/Purpose strategy. This 0.01 per cent would even be enough to give, I repeat, a certain competitive advantage to these sports organizations, attracting new sponsors, participating in the retention of employees, and the commitment of fans etc.
With a few hundred thousand euros, a sports organization could publicly position itself on the integration of biodiversity issues and the operationalization of sustainable and resilient solutions by carrying out certain concrete actions.
Structuring an environmental CSR process to establish a clear and precise roadmap of the club's maturity in terms of "sustainable development" issues and its commitments. They include analysis of its carbon footprint and reduction/compensation methodology, reduction of water and energy costs, analysis of waste management, structuring a biodiversity policy, and accelerating the transition to sustainable mobility.
I am now convinced of one thing; if sports organizations do not take the plunge of this ongoing impact revolution, this Purpose revolution, if they do not integrate these eco-responsibility issues, then they will suffer in the decades to come. This is undeniable.
They will be structurally threatened in their very essence, and the millions of euros of these famous staggering amounts of transfers and other salaries, will have no meaning at all.
If they don't do it, the people, the revolted youth, will rise up and will demand account. As it is, we are already beginning to see it in some big sports events: Roland Garros, the Tour de France, and tomorrow, the Olympics, and the World Cups. We can't say that we didn't know.
Let's hear it.
_________________________________________________________________________________________________
About the author
Francois Singer is specialized in International Marketing and Innovation. He also specialized in in the field of Sports Organization Management and Eco-Responsibility. Singer has, among others, worked with the think tank 'Sport and Citizenship', the 2024 French Olympic Committee, and UNESCO.
Activity